The JT/DL is a twice-monthly newsletter about justice technology news, events, and opportunities. My opinions do not reflect those of my employers or professional partners.
An Affordability Agenda runs through the Courts
Mark Douglas was promoted and fired from his job on the same day.
The astounding turn of events rested on old misdemeanor charges in his criminal record. All wasn’t lost though. He was told, according to the CT Mirror, that he could keep his job if he cleared his record through the state’s Clean Slate law passed in 2021. The problem was that the state struggled to make the law operational. Douglas was out of luck and out of a job.
Douglas wasn’t alone. Nearly 120,000 Connecticut residents were waiting for the state to clear old criminal records that kept them from jobs, housing, and other economic opportunities.
The delay lasted years. But, in a country accustomed to gridlock, the biggest obstacle wasn’t politics—it was IT. The law required court and law enforcement records systems to reconcile and speak to each other—an impossible ask at the time—and the state’s outdated computer systems and poor data quality made it hard to know whether a person’s record should be erased at all.
The intent of the law wasn’t fully realized until this year, five years after it passed.
“I’ve been carrying this record for years, and I mean, like carrying it like a weight on your chest that never lets up,” Miss Smith, a Connecticut resident, said at a Clean Slate event this year. “Every job application, every interview.” Once her record was cleared, she said, “It gave me back my dignity. It gave me back my future.”
The affordability crisis in America has many drivers: inflation, war, slow housing starts. But as Connecticut learned, it’s also driven by bad data, systems that can’t talk to each other, and outdated technology. In a word, it’s the plumbing. And when the court’s technical plumbing fails, people are locked out of work, hit with wage garnishments and liens, and pushed out of safe housing.
To put it another way: an affordability agenda runs through the courts.
A National Crisis
Connecticut’s experience is not unique. Versions of Clean Slate have passed in 13 states and D.C. States, including Louisiana, Michigan, New Jersey, and Utah, have all struggled. These failures are expensive. Connecticut spent $8 million on IT upgrades before its first big expungement announcement. In Louisiana, the problem is a lack of money: implementation of its 2023 law was tied to future funding, and the state hasn’t yet paid for the technology.
While a costly headache for government employees, the cost falls hardest on the people these laws were meant to help. A criminal record is a scarlet letter in the U.S., keeping people from gainful employment, housing, and public benefits. Removing it from public view can increase quarterly wages by about 23% within a year. But timing matters, as research indicates that clearing a record years later does little, because a criminal record’s damage is done early, which makes every year of delay costly.
What’s so frustrating is that the incredible promise of these laws—shifting the burden from individuals to the system itself—is held up by problems other industries have largely solved, like entity resolution and interoperability. And it isn’t just a criminal records issue. Incomplete and inaccurate court data also shows up in eviction records, which, when used by future landlords, can push people out of secure housing and into unhealthy and unsafe conditions.
The problems go deeper than data quality, though. Take text message reminders, a reform with broad support across the political spectrum.
Reminders matter because missing a criminal or even minor traffic hearing can lead to a bench warrant and arrest. In civil court, missing a hearing means a default judgment for the plaintiff, regardless of the quality of the case. That’s especially impactful in debt cases, which make up about a quarter of civil cases nationnallyand where most defendants represent themselves. A default judgment can quickly become a wage garnishment, a lien on property, and harassing calls from debt collectors.
Yet text message reminders are not the norm in courts, partly because of two technical factors. First, as with Clean Slate, the data in many courts’ backends isn’t good enough to automate accurate reminders. Second, even courts that have invested in better data are hobbled by brittle or nonexistent APIs. That lack of interoperability drives up costs to the state through arrests and incarceration, and pushes people who miss court further behind. Pew estimates that preventable missed hearings cost Virginia alone more than $3 million a year. For the people missing their day in court, reminders, which cost a few cents, can improve court attendance by as much as 53%. Yet automated court date reminders remain the exception.
Fix the Plumbing
As I’ve written before, bad courts eat good policy. They can eat affordability too. So what can be done?
First, Congress should pass the Open Courts Act. The bipartisan bill would build a secure, modern case management system for the federal courts and make its code available to any state, local, tribal, or territorial court that wants it. That would bring unprecedented federal resources to an underappreciated national problem, and build common infrastructure needed by every court. If you want to take on the plumbing problem head-on, this bill does it.
Second, fund a corps of forward-deployed engineers who work inside courts with court staff to tackle entity resolution and interoperability, while building new solutions to the affordability crisis. This was the promise of the Judicial Innovation Fellowship, which brought technologists and designers into courts to improve how they work and serve the public. The pilot developed accessible websites with structured information hierarchy, improved data sharing, and led to internal improvements at courts, like the adoption of agile product management processes. With the AI boom underway and court budgets under pressure, this model is needed more than ever.
With more technical talent in courts, promising tools can get built and deployed. Courts in California, Indiana, and Pennsylvania are developing AI tools to check whether debt lawsuits meet statutory requirements before they move forward. The need is clear. In Connecticut, researchers reviewed 88 debt-buyer cases in small claims court and found that none of the plaintiffs met the state’s documentation requirements. Courts entered default judgments in most of them anyway, opening the door to wage garnishments and liens against people who may not even owe the debt. This type of automation—flagging missing information and defects—is the very thing AI is good at. The same approach could eventually screen defective eviction filings and service of process, checking the most predatory cases before people get pulled into the downward economic spiral that follows.
Bring Courts to the Table
The courts sit at a critical intersection between the government, the public, and the economy. Criminal records, housing, and debt will keep washing through these institutions. As long as the plumbing courts rely on is broken, every sealable criminal record left public, court date missed, and defective debt case decided against a defendant makes America less affordable. Courts can help build a more affordable America, but only if they are treated as the indispensable partner that they are.
Mark Douglas was promoted and fired on the same day. He was told a law passed in 2021 could save his job, but the state’s technology took five years to catch up. Proof that when the plumbing breaks, it’s the public who are stuck with the bill.
News
Prisons are teaming up with an AI software company to predict when incarcerated people will commit future crimes. (Futurism) (h/t Keith Porcaro)
Microsoft outage hits courts. (Axios)
India ordered website takedowns on fake court orders. (Reuters)
Reflecting on three years of LegalBench. (Neel Guha)
Penn Law trains judges to embrace AI as a virtual law clerk. (Axios)
Randomized control trial throws cold water on expungement access. (A2J Lab)
Seattle’s real-time crime center: A Civil rights, civil liberties, and governance audit. (Policing Project)
AI and the potential for universal affordable access to front-line justice. (ODI) (h/t Clare Manuel)
Events
eCourts is in Las Vegas December 7-9. (NCSC)
NACDL is hosting an AI in Law CLE in Philly May 26-28. (NACDL)
Jobs & Opportunities
Anthropic is accepting economic futures research applications. (A)
Arnold Ventures is hiring for a chief of staff for its criminal justice team. (AV) (h/t Keith Porcaro)
The Brennan Center for Justice has multiple openings. (BCJ)
[New] The Center for Democracy and Technology has multiple positions, including academic externships. (CDT)
CGI needs a director for AI consulting on national security and justice issues. (CGI)
The University of Chicago Crime Lab has multiple openings. (UCCL)
Code for America has multiple openings. (CfA) (h/t Russ Finkelstein)
Draper Richards Kaplan Foundation and NextLadder Ventures launched the navigation tech initiative. (DRK) (h/t Keith Porcaro)
[New] Duke announced the F. M. Kirby Prize for Scaling Impact award. (FMK)
The Free Law Project needs a director of philanthropy. (FLP)
The German Marshall Fund of the U.S. needs a tech policy fellow. (GMF)
Go From Here is hiring for multiple roles. (GFH)
[New] Harvard’s Computational Policy Lab needs a senior software developer. (CPL)
Northeastern is hiring professors focused on AI governance. (NEU) (h/t Matthew Burnett)
[New] The Open AI Foundation needs a chief of staff for civil society. (OAI)
The Philadelphia District Attorney’s Office needs a analytics engineer. (PDAO) (h/t Oren Gur)
Ready State Labs is hiring a founding team. (RSL)
Recidiviz has multiple openings. (R)
[New] Renaissance Philanthropy is hiring for multiple roles. (RP)
Rockefeller Foundation and Open AI have $50M for local governments working on AI. (RF)
[New] Travis County, TX needs a data reporting analyst. (TCTX)
The Urban Institute needs a senior director for their AI studio. (UI)


